Nevis particle-physics administrative cluster configuration

Archived 20-Sep-2013: The high-availability cluster has been set aside in favor of a more traditional single-box admin server. HA is grand in theory, but in the three years we operated the cluster we had no hardware problems which the HA set-up would have prevented, but many hours of downtime due to problems with the HA software. This mailing-list post has some details.

This is a reference page. It contains a text file that describes how the high-availability Pacemaker/Corosync configuration was set up on two administrative servers, hypatia and orestes.


Key HA configuration files. Note: Even in an emergency, there's no reason to edit these files:

/home/bin/ # Daily rsync from hypatia to orestes:


The configuration has definitely changed from that listed below. To see the current configuration, run this as root on either hypatia or orestes:

crm configure show
To get a constantly-updated display of the resource status, the following command is the corosync equivalent of "top" (use Ctrl-C to exit):
For a GUI, you can use this utility. You have to select "Connect" and login via an account that's a member of the haclient group; you may have to edit /etc/group.
crm_gui &
You can run the above commands via sudo, but you'll have to extend your path; e.g.,
export PATH=/sbin:/usr/sbin:${PATH}
sudo crm_mon


This may help as you work your way through the configuration:

crm configure primitive IP ocf:heartbeat:IPaddr2 params ip= \
   cidr_netmask=32 op monitor interval=30s

# Which is composed of
    * crm ::= "cluster resource manager", the command we're executing
    * primitive ::= The type of resource object that we’re creating.
    * IP ::= Our name for the resource
    * IPaddr2 ::= The script to call
    * ocf ::= The standard it conforms to
    * ip= ::= Parameter(s) as name/value pairs
    * cidr_netmask ::= netmask; 32-bits means use this exact IP address
    * op ::== what follows are options
    * monitor interval=30s ::= check every 30 seconds that this resource is working

# ... timeout = how to long wait before you assume a resource is dead. 

How to find out which scripts exist, that is, which resources can be controlled by the HA cluster:

ra classes
Based on the result, I looked at:
ra list ocf heartbeat
To find out what IPaddr2 parameters I needed, I used:
ra meta ocf:heartbeat:IPaddr2


This work was done in Sep-2010, with major revisions for stability in Aug-2011. The configuration has almost certainly changed since then. Hopefully, the following commands and comments will guide you to understanding any future changes and the reasons for them.

# The commands ultimately used to configure the high-availability (HA) servers:

# The beginning: make sure corosync is running on both hypatia and orestes:

/sbin/service corosync start

# The following line is needed because we have only two machines in 
# the HA cluster.

crm configure property no-quorum-policy=ignore

# We'll configure STONITH later (see below)

crm configure property stonith-enabled=false

# Define IP addresses to be managed by the HA systems.

crm configure primitive ClusterIP ocf:heartbeat:IPaddr2 params ip= \
   cidr_netmask=32 op monitor interval=30s
crm configure primitive LocalIP ocf:heartbeat:IPaddr2 params ip= \
   cidr_netmask=32 op monitor interval=30s
crm configure primitive SandboxIP ocf:heartbeat:IPaddr2 params ip= \
   cidr_netmask=32 op monitor interval=30s
# Group these together, so they'll all be assigned to the same machine.
# The name of the group is "MainIPGroup".

crm configure group MainIPGroup ClusterIP LocalIP SandboxIP

# Let's continue by entering the crm utility for short sessions. I'm going to 
# test groups of commands before I commit them. (I omit the "configure show' 
# and "status" commands that I frequently typed in, in order to see that 
# everything was correct.)
# DRBD is a service that synchronizes the hard drives between two machines.
# For our cluster, one machine will have access to the "master" copy
# and make all the changes to that copy; the other machine will have the
# "slave" copy and mindlessly duplicate all the changes.

# I previously configured the DRBD resources 'admin' and 'work'. What the 
# following commands do is put the maintenance of these resources under
# the control of Pacemaker. 

   # Define a "shadow" configuration, to test things without committing them
   # to the HA cluster:
   cib new drbd
   # The "drbd_resource" parameter points to a configuration defined in /etc/drbd.d/
   configure primitive AdminDrbd ocf:linbit:drbd params drbd_resource=admin op monitor interval=60s
   # DRBD functions with a "master/slave" setup as described above. The following command
   # defines the name of the master disk partition ("Admin"). The remaining parameters
   # clarify that there are two copies, but only one can be the master, and
   # at most one can be a slave.
   configure master Admin AdminDrbd meta master-max=1 master-node-max=1 \
      clone-max=2 clone-node-max=1 notify=true globally-unique=false
   # The machine that gets the master copy (the one that will make changes to the drive)
   # should also be the one with the main IP address.
   configure colocation AdminWithMainIP inf: MainIPGroup Admin:Master

   # We want to wait before assigning IPs to a node until we know that
   # Admin has been promoted to master on that node. 
   configure order AdminBeforeMainIP inf: Admin:promote MainIPGroup

   # I like these commands, so commit them to the running configuration.
   cib commit drbd
   # Things look good, so let's add another disk resource. I defined another drbd resource
   # with some spare disk space, called "work". The idea is that I can play with alternate 
   # virtual machines and save them on "work" before I copy them to the more robust "admin".
   configure primitive WorkDrbd ocf:linbit:drbd params drbd_resource=work op monitor interval=60s
   configure master Work WorkDrbd meta master-max=1 master-node-max=1 \
      clone-max=2 clone-node-max=1 notify=true globally-unique=false
   # I prefer the work directory to be on the main admin box, but it doesn't have to be. "500:" is 
   # weighting factor; compare it to "inf:" (for infinity) which is used in most of these commands. 
   configure colocation WorkPrefersMain 500: Work:Master MainIPGroup
   # Given a choice, try to put the Admin:Master on hypatia
   configure location DefinePreferredMainNode Admin 100:

   cib commit drbd

# Now try a resource that depends on ordering: On the node that has the master
# resource for "work," mount that disk image as /work.
   cib new workdisk
   # To find out that there was an "ocf:heartbeat:Filesystem" that I could use,
   # I used the command:
   ra classes
   # Based on the result, I looked at:
   ra list ocf heartbeat
   # To find out what Filesystem parameters I needed, I used:
   ra meta ocf:heartbeat:Filesystem
   # All of the above led me to create the following resource configuration:
   configure primitive WorkDirectory ocf:heartbeat:Filesystem \
      params device="/dev/drbd2" directory="/work" fstype="ext4"
   # Note that I had previously created an ext4 filesystem on /dev/drbd2.
   # Now specify that we want this to be on the same node as Work:Master:
   configure colocation DirectoryWithWork inf: WorkDirectory Work:Master
   # One more thing: It's important that we not try to mount the directory
   # until after Work has been promoted to master on the node.
   # A score of "inf" means "infinity"; if the DRBD resource 'work' can't
   # be set up, then don't mount the /work partition. 
   configure order WorkBeforeDirectory inf: Work:promote WorkDirectory:start
   cib commit workdisk

# We've made the relatively-unimportant DRBD resource 'work' function. Let's do it for 'admin'.
# Previously I created some LVM volumes on the admin DRBD master. We need to use a 
# resource to active them, but we can't activate them until after the Admin:Master
# is loaded.
   cib new lvm
   # Activate the LVM volumes, but only after DRBD has figured out where
   # Admin:Master is located.
   configure primitive Lvm ocf:heartbeat:LVM \
      params volgrpname="admin"
   configure colocation LvmWithAdmin inf: Lvm Admin:Master
   configure order AdminBeforeLvm inf: Admin:promote Lvm:start
   cib commit lvm
   # Go back to the actual, live configuration
   cib use live
   # See if everything is working
   configure show 
   # Go back to the shadow for more commands.
   cib use lvm
   # We have a whole bunch of filesystems on the "admin" volume group. Let's
   # create the commands to mount them.
   # The 'timeout="240s' piece is to give a four-minute interval to start
   # up the mount. This allows for a "it's been too long, do an fsck" check
   # on mounting the filesystem. 
   # We also allow five minutes for the unmounting to stop, just in case 
   # it's taking a while for some job on server to let go of the mount.
   # It's better that it take a while to switch over the system service
   # than for the mount to be forcibly terminated.
   configure primitive UsrDirectory ocf:heartbeat:Filesystem \
      params device="/dev/admin/usr" directory="/usr/nevis" fstype="ext4" \
      op start interval="0" timeout="240s" \
      op stop interval="0" timeout="300s"
   configure primitive VarDirectory ocf:heartbeat:Filesystem \
      params device="/dev/admin/var" directory="/var/nevis" fstype="ext4" \
      op start interval="0" timeout="240s" \
      op stop interval="0" timeout="300s"
   configure primitive MailDirectory ocf:heartbeat:Filesystem \
      params device="/dev/admin/mail" directory="/mail" fstype="ext4" \
      op start interval="0" timeout="240s" \
      op stop interval="0" timeout="300s"
   configure primitive XenDirectory ocf:heartbeat:Filesystem \
      params device="/dev/admin/xen" directory="/xen" fstype="ext4" \
      op start interval="0" timeout="240s" \
      op stop interval="0" timeout="300s"
   configure group AdminDirectoriesGroup UsrDirectory VarDirectory MailDirectory XenDirectory
   # We can't mount any of them until LVM is set up:
   configure colocation DirectoriesWithLVM inf: AdminDirectoriesGroup Lvm
   configure order LvmBeforeDirectories inf: Lvm AdminDirectoriesGroup

   cib commit lvm

# Some standard Linux services are under corosync's control. They depend on some or
# all of the filesystems being mounted. 
# Let's start with a simple one: enable the printing service (cups):

   cib new printing
   # lsb = "Linux Standard Base." It just means any service which is
   # controlled by the one of the standard scripts in /etc/init.d
   configure primitive Cups lsb:cups
   # Cups stores its spool files in /var/spool/cups. If the cups service 
   # were to switch to a different server, we want the new server to see 
   # the spooled files. So create /var/nevis/cups, link it with:
   #   mv /var/spool/cups /var/spool/cups.ori
   #   ln -sf /var/nevis/cups /var/spool/cups
   # and demand that the cups service only start if /var/nevis (and the other
   # high-availability directories) have been mounted.
   configure colocation CupsWithVar inf: Cups AdminDirectoriesGroup
   # In order to prevent chaos, make sure that the high-availability directories
   # have been mounted before we try to start cups.
   configure order VarBeforeCups inf: AdminDirectoriesGroup Cups
   cib commit printing

# The other services (xinetd, dhcpd) follow the same pattern as above:
# Make sure the services start on the same machine as the admin directories,
# and after the admin directories are successfully mounted.

   cib new services
   configure primitive Xinetd lsb:xinetd
   configure primitive Dhcpd lsb:dhcpd
   configure colocation XinetdWithVar inf: Xinetd AdminDirectoriesGroup
   configure order VarBeforeXinetd inf: VarDirectory Xinetd
   configure colocation DhcpdWithVar inf: Dhcpd AdminDirectoriesGroup
   configure order VarBeforeDhcpd inf: VarDirectory Dhcpd
   cib commit services

# The high-availability servers export some of the admin directories to other
# systems, both real and virtual; for example, the /usr/nevis directory is 
# exported to all the other machines on the Nevis Linux cluster. 

# NFS exporting of a shared directory can be a little tricky. As with CUPS 
# spooling, we want to preserve the NFS export state in a way that the 
# backup server can pick it up. The safest way to do this is to create a 
# small separate LVM partition ("nfs") and mount it as "/var/lib/nfs",
# the NFS directory that contains files that keep track of the NFS state.

   cib new nfs
   # Define the mount for the NFS state directory /var/lib/nfs
   configure primitive NfsStateDirectory ocf:heartbeat:Filesystem \
         params device="/dev/admin/nfs" directory="/var/lib/nfs" fstype="ext4"
   configure colocation NfsStateWithVar inf: NfsStateDirectory AdminDirectoriesGroup
   configure order VarBeforeNfsState inf: AdminDirectoriesGroup NfsStateDirectory

   # Now that the NFS state directory is mounted, we can start nfslockd. Note that
   # that we're starting NFS lock on both the primary and secondary HA systems;
   # by default a "clone" resource is started on all systems in a cluster. 

   # (Placing nfslockd under the control of Pacemaker turned out to be key to
   # successful transfer of cluster services to another node. The nfslockd and
   # nfs daemon information stored in /var/lib/nfs have to be consistent.)

   configure primitive NfsLockInstance lsb:nfslock
   configure clone NfsLock NfsLockInstance

   configure order NfsStateBeforeNfsLock inf: NfsStateDirectory NfsLock

   # Once nfslockd has been set up, we can start NFS. (We say to colocate
   # NFS with 'NfsStateDirectory', instead of nfslockd, because nfslockd
   # is going to be started on both nodes.)
   configure primitive Nfs lsb:nfs
   configure colocation NfsWithNfsState inf: Nfs NfsStateDirectory
   configure order NfsLockBeforeNfs inf: NfsLock Nfs 
   cib commit nfs

# The whole point of the entire setup is to be able to run guest virtual machines 
# under the control of the high-availability service. Here is the set-up for one example
# virtual machine. I previously created the hogwarts virtual machine and copied its
# configuration to /xen/configs/hogwarts.cfg.

# I duplicated the same procedure for franklin (mail server), ada (web server), and
# so on, but I don't show that here.

   cib new hogwarts
   # Give the virtual machine a long stop interval before flagging an error.
   # Sometimes it takes a while for Linux to shut down.
   configure primitive Hogwarts ocf:heartbeat:Xen params \
      xmfile="/xen/configs/Hogwarts.cfg" \
         op stop interval="0" timeout="240"

   # All the virtual machine files are stored in the /xen partition, which is one
   # of the high-availability admin directories. The virtual machine must run on
   # the system with this directory.

   configure colocation HogwartsWithDirectories inf: Hogwarts AdminDirectoriesGroup

   # All of the virtual machines depend on NFS-mounting directories which
   # are exported by the HA server. The safest thing to do is to make sure
   # NFS is running on the HA server before starting the virtual machine.
   configure order NfsBeforeHogwarts inf: Nfs Hogwarts
   cib commit hogwarts

# An important part of a high-availability configuration is STONITH = "Shoot the
# other node in the head." Here's the idea: suppose one node fails for some reason. The
# other node will take over as needed. 

# Suppose the failed node tries to come up again. This can be a problem: The other node
# may have accumulated changes that the failed node doesn't know about. There can be
# synchronization issues that require manual intervention.

# The STONITH mechanism means: If a node fails, the remaining node(s) in a cluster will
# force a permanent shutdown of the failed node; it can't automatically come back up again.
# This is a special case of "fencing": once a node or resource fails, it can't be allowed
# to start up again automatically.

# In general, there are many ways to implement a STONITH mechanism. At Nevis, the way
# we do it is to shut-off the power on the UPS connected to the failed node.

# (By the way, this is why you have to be careful about restarting hypatia or orestes.
# The STONITH mechanism may cause the UPS on the restarting
# computer to turn off the power; it will never come back up.)

# At Nevis, the UPSes are monitored and controlled using the NUT package
# <>; details are on the Nevis wiki at
# <>.

# The official corosync distribution from <> 
# does not include a script for NUT, so I had to write one. It's located at
# /home/bin/ on both hypatia and orestes; there are appropriate links
# to this script from the stonith/external directory. 

# By the way, I sent the script to Cluster Labs, who accepted it.
# The next generation of their distribution will include the script.

# The following commands implement the STONITH mechanism for our cluster:

   cib new stonith
   # The STONITH resource that can potentially shut down hypatia.
   configure primitive HypatiaStonith stonith:external/nut \
      params hostname="" \
      ups="hypatia-ups" username="admin" password="acdc"
   # The node that runs the above script cannot be hypatia; it's
   # not wise to trust a node to STONITH itself. Note that the score
   # is "negative infinity," which means "never run this resource
   # on the named node."

   configure location HypatiaStonithLoc HypatiaStonith -inf:

   # The STONITH resource that can potentially shut down orestes.

   configure primitive OrestesStonith stonith:external/nut \
      params hostname="" \
      ups="orestes-ups" username="admin" password="acdc"

   # Again, orestes cannot be the node that runs the above script.
   configure location OresetesStonithLoc OrestesStonith -inf:
   cib commit stonith

# Now turn the STONITH mechanism on for the cluster.

crm configure property stonith-enabled=true

# At this point, the key elements of the high-availability configuration have
# been set up. There is one non-critical frill: One node (probably hypatia) will be 
# running the important services, while the other node (probably orestes) would
# be "twiddling its thumbs." Instead, let's have orestes do something useful: execute
# condor jobs.

# For orestes to do this, it requires the condor service. It also requires that
# library:/usr/nevis is mounted, the same as every other batch machine on the
# Nevis condor cluster. We can't use the automount daemon (amd) to do this for
# us, the way we do on the other batch nodes; we have to make corosync do the
# mounts.

   cib new condor
   # Mount library:/usr/nevis. A bit of a name confusion here: there's a /work
   # partition on the primary node, but the name 'LibraryOnWork" means that
   # the nfs-mount of /usr/nevis is located on the secondary or "work" node.
   configure primitive LibraryOnWork ocf:heartbeat:Filesystem \
      params device="library:/usr/nevis" directory="/usr/nevis" \
   # Corosync must not NFS-mount library:/usr/nevis on the system has already 
   # mounted /usr/nevis directly as part of AdminDirectoriesGroup
   # described above. 
   # Note that if there's only one node remaining in the high-availability 
   # cluster, it will be running the resource AdminDirectoriesGroup, and 
   # LibraryOnWork will never be started. This is fine; if there's only one
   # node left, I _don't_ want it running condor jobs.
   configure colocation NoRemoteMountWithDirectories -inf: LibraryOnWork AdminDirectoriesGroup

   # Determine on which machine we mount library:/usr/nevis _after_ the NFS
   # export of /usr/nevis has been set up.  
   configure order NfsBeforeLibrary inf: Nfs LibraryOnWork

   # Define the IPs associated with the backup system, and group them together.
   # This is a non-critical definition, and I don't want to assign it until the more important
   # "secondary" resources have been set up. 

   configure primitive Burr ocf:heartbeat:IPaddr2 params ip= \
      cidr_netmask=32 op monitor interval=30s
   configure primitive BurrLocal ocf:heartbeat:IPaddr2 params ip= 
      cidr_netmask=32 op monitor interval=30s
   configure group AssistantIPGroup Burr BurrLocal

   colocation AssistantWithLibrary inf: AssistantIPGroup LibraryOnWork
   order LibraryBeforeAssistant inf: LibraryOnWork AssistantIPGroup

   # The standard condor execution service. As with all the batch nodes,
   # I've already configured /etc/condor/condor_config.local and created
   # scratch directories in /data/condor.
   configure primitive Condor lsb:condor

   # If we're able mount library:/usr/nevis, then it's safe to start condor.
   # If we can't mount library:/usr/nevis, then condor will never be started.
   # (We stated above that AssistantIPGroup won't start until after LibraryOnWork).
   configure colocation CondorWithAssistant inf: Condor AssistantIPGroup
   configure order AssistantBeforeCondor inf: AssistantIPGroup Condor
   cib commit condor
Edit | Attach | Watch | Print version | History: r10 < r9 < r8 < r7 < r6 | Backlinks | Raw View | Raw edit | More topic actions
Topic revision: r10 - 2014-07-01 - WilliamSeligman
This site is powered by the TWiki collaboration platform Powered by PerlCopyright © 2008-2018 by the contributing authors. All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
Ideas, requests, problems regarding TWiki? Send feedback